Protein confusion is just more diet dogma—loud opinions with very little clarity. If you’ve ever wondered why you’re “eating well” but still feel weak, tired, achy, or muscularly soft despite working out… this might be why.
Somewhere along the way, protein stopped being a nutrient and turned into a belief system. Animal protein got labeled “problematic.” Plant protein got crowned “just as good.” And a whole lot of people—especially women—ended up under-muscled, under-fueled, and frustrated.
Let’s bring this conversation back to reality. Not ideology. Not trends. Human physiology.
Because while plant foods are incredibly valuable, plant protein does not function the same way as animal protein in the body—and pretending otherwise is one of the quiet reasons so many health-conscious people feel worse instead of better.
This post contains affiliate links meaning I make a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting the work of Lisa Smith Wellness and the Pretty Well Podcast!
Protein 101: What It Actually Does (and Why Your Body Cares)
Protein isn’t just about biceps and booty gains—although, yes, it does help there too.
At a cellular level, protein is structural. Think of it like Lego bricks for your body. Hair, skin, enzymes, hormones, neurotransmitters, immune cells, connective tissue—all of it relies on protein. No protein, no building blocks. And no one wants a renovation project with missing materials.
Protein is made up of 20 standard amino acids, and 9 of them are essential, meaning your body can’t make them on its own. You have to get them from food. Every single day.
Here’s the critical part that often gets glossed over:
👉 Not all proteins deliver these amino acids in the same amounts, ratios, or bioavailable forms.
Your body doesn’t just need protein on paper.
It needs protein it can actually use.
Complete Proteins Are Not a Myth — They’re a Biological Advantage
Let’s be clear.
Complete proteins matter.
And animal proteins are, unequivocally, superior in this category.
Animal proteins:
- Contain all nine essential amino acids
- Provide them in ratios that support muscle protein synthesis (read: makes more muscle)
- Are highly bioavailable (your body absorbs and uses more of what you eat)
- Are rich in leucine, the amino acid that directly triggers muscle building and metabolic signaling
Plant proteins, by contrast:
- Are often low in one or more essential amino acids
- Require combining, planning, and higher total intake to approach adequacy
- Are less bioavailable due to fiber, phytates, and antinutrients
- Deliver less leucine per gram, making them less anabolic (less able to contribute to muscle development)
As a dietitian, I’ll spill the tea:
Gram for gram, plant protein does not hold a candle to animal protein for maintaining muscle, metabolism, and resilience—especially in women, mid-life and older adults, and anyone under stress.
That doesn’t make plant protein bad—coming from a proud veggie-pusher. It just means biology gets the final say.
Why People Can Feel Worse When They Go All-in on a “Plants Only Diet” (Even When They Do It Right)
I’ve seen this pattern over and over.
People clean up their diet. Add more plants. Reduce or eliminate animal protein.
At first, they feel lighter. Less bloated. Maybe even energized.
Then…
- Muscle tone softens
- Hair thins
- Energy drops
- Blood sugar gets shaky
- Workouts feel harder
- Recovery slows
- Hunger becomes hanger
What’s happening isn’t a detox.
It’s nutrition inadequacy disguised as wellness.
Most people simply do not eat enough plant protein—or enough variety—to meet their true physiological needs long-term.
And for women in midlife, this matters even more.
Wondering where to start with adding more protein to your diet? This is my favorite cookbook for high-protein, nutrient-rich recipes – plus, they’re delicious and easy to make!
Where Plant Proteins Do Shine (When Used Strategically)
Now, here’s where nuance comes in.
Plant proteins absolutely have an important role in a healthy diet. Just not as a one-for-one replacement for animal protein.
They shine when they:
- Complement animal protein, not replace it entirely
- Add much-needed fiber, minerals, and polyphenols
- Support gut health and metabolic flexibility
- Improve meal diversity and micronutrient density
Used wisely, plant proteins make animal protein work better.
Plant-Based Protein Sources That Actually Pull Their Weight
Let’s get practical. These are plant proteins I regularly recommend because they’re nutrient-dense, versatile, and realistic for real life.
Hemp Seeds
Quietly powerful.
Three tablespoons = ~10 grams of protein plus omega-3s. They’re mild, blend well, and don’t hijack the flavor of your meal.
Sprinkle them on salads, soups, unsweetened Greek yogurt, roasted veggies, or blend into smoothies.
Bonus: they’re one of the few seeds that offer a complete amino acid profile on their own.
Pumpkin Seeds
Underrated and impressive.
They provide protein, magnesium, zinc, and iron—nutrients many women are low in.
Quinoa & Amaranth
Ancient grains with modern relevance.
- Quinoa: ~8 grams of protein per cooked cup (*also offers a complete amino acid profile on its own)
- Amaranth: ~9 grams per cup
They’re naturally gluten-free, satisfying, and far more blood-sugar-friendly than most refined grains.
Lentils, Chickpeas & Green Peas
Legumes are protein workhorses.
Yes, they’re slightly lower in methionine—but pair them with seeds, nuts, or whole grains and you’re golden. Plus, they feed your gut bacteria like champions.
Anecdotally? When clients stop fearing legumes, digestion usually improves, not worsens—especially when portions are reasonable and prep is solid. It’s important to remember the “go low and slow” rule – start by adding a small amount of legumes to your diet initially to keep gas and G.I. symptoms at bay.
Nutritional Yeast
Cheesy, savory, oddly addictive.
It adds protein and B12 (a big win for plant-forward eaters). Sprinkle it on roasted veggies, popcorn, or grain bowls.
Spirulina
Potent, concentrated, and not something you need a ton of.
It’s extremely high in protein by weight and brings antioxidants to the party. Pair it with other plant proteins to make a complete protein and round things out.
A Note on Soy (and Why It’s Optional)
Soy gets a lot of press—both glowing and scary.
The truth is nuanced. Fermented soy can work well for some people, and it’s one of the few plant proteins that has all 9 essential amino acids (along with quinoa and hemp hearts).
The key is to buy only organic soy products. In the U.S., soy is a “Roundup Ready” crop, meaning that it is doused with Roundup during the growing process which becomes systemic and cannot be washed off.
I’ve worked with many women who feel better minimizing soy—and many who tolerate it just fine. The key is individual response, not dietary dogma.
Good news: protein diversity means you have options.
The Protein Target That Actually Supports Health
For most women:
- 25–35 grams of high-quality protein per meal
- Prioritize animal protein as the anchor
- Use plant proteins to round out the plate
This approach:
- Preserves muscle
- Stabilizes blood sugar
- Supports hormones and brain chemistry
- Improves satiety and energy
And yes—people feel the difference when they stop under-proteining themselves in the name of wellness.
What About Plant-Based Protein Powders?
They can help—but they’re not a replacement for all animal protein in your diet.
Pea, rice, and hemp protein powders:
- Require higher doses
- Are less leucine-rich
- Often need blending to approach completeness
They’re useful to work into your diet along with animal protein—but not as a foundational replacement.
The Big Picture: Protein, Aging, and Long-Term Strength
Here’s the truth about fueling your body well:
Under-eating animal protein accelerates muscle loss, metabolic slowdown, and frailty over time. It also contributes to food cravings, blood sugar instability, and premature aging.
Muscle isn’t about aesthetics.
It’s a longevity organ.
It regulates glucose, protects bones, supports cognition, boosts immunity, and determines how strong you feel in your body.
Plant foods support health and wellness.
Animal protein preserves structure.
You need both.
Bottom Line
You don’t need to choose sides.
You need to choose function.
Plant proteins are supportive.
Animal proteins are foundational.
When you understand that difference—and build meals accordingly—everything gets easier: energy, metabolism, body composition, and confidence in your choices.
And that’s exactly the kind of grounded, no-BS nutrition approach we take inside Brains & Beauty, my six-week signature course designed for women who want to feel strong, sharp, and deeply at home in their bodies again.
Want more conversations like this? Listen to the Pretty Well Podcast—where evidence meets real life.
Because feeling good shouldn’t require solving a nutritional Sudoku every time you eat.
It should require clarity.
+ view comments . . .